WILCO
+10
basil
Uncle_Remus
Yann G.
Frenchy
Al
Lee Harvey Oswald
parispal
crazychester
Grievous Angel
Hugues
14 participants
Page 2 sur 2
Page 2 sur 2 • 1, 2
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Qui a dit que youtube ne servait pas la discussion? merci pour ces liens!
johnny99- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 2158
Date d'inscription : 25/05/2005
Re: WILCO
Le nouveau Wilco est prévu pour juin, si l'on en croit Rolling Stone.
Qu'un tel groupe puisse continuer d'exister à l'heure actuelle relève du miracle.
C'est ce que je me dis à chaque fois que j'ai des nouvelles d'eux. Ma façon de dire que ça me fait toujours un plaisir fou de les savoir créatifs, et de savoir que je vais écouter un nouvel album d'eux cet été.
Qu'un tel groupe puisse continuer d'exister à l'heure actuelle relève du miracle.
C'est ce que je me dis à chaque fois que j'ai des nouvelles d'eux. Ma façon de dire que ça me fait toujours un plaisir fou de les savoir créatifs, et de savoir que je vais écouter un nouvel album d'eux cet été.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Waou. Tu sais quoi, Yann? Je trouve ton papier sur poin-poin tellement bon que je vais aller le promouvoir sur le forum du groupe! Ils n'ont qu'à apprendre le français, ces cons!
Et je vais m'acheter ce DVD. Il est dispo en zone adéquate chez nous j'espère?
Et je vais m'acheter ce DVD. Il est dispo en zone adéquate chez nous j'espère?
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Tiens, sur le forum de Wilco dont je parlais, une critique intéressante du DVD:
Like millions (well maybe thousands) of Wilco fans, I watched the DVD last night. I had seen it at the Music Box a few weeks back so I knew what to expect. I have a few things to say also and the thing about the Tulsa/Nashville thing is something I couldn't know about, but I have some other issues with the movie.
First some of backpedaling before I wade into some shit....I know the band reads stuff here and maybe the film makers do too, I don't know. I am an old fan of Wilco and have talked to all the band members on one occasion or another over the years. They are all massively talented and interesting people. A movie could be made about any one of them and I would buy it or watch it. So just like every other fan here I love seeing and hearing them in the comfort of my livingroom. But if my comments piss some people off, sorry about that.
My issues are not with the band, but with the narrative of the film. I love the concert footage and will watch the movie for that repeatedly in the future, but the flow of the movie (as a film) is so broken up it is very distracting. If all we want (and maybe this is simply a fan movie and nothing else) is to see our favorite band play some songs, this movie fits the bill, but as a movie; well not so much.
Where do I start? Even during the initial viewing at the Music Box, I developed a small internal joke which was "Bye Pat." Seeing snippets of several different shows including some sound checks is really distracting. So we get see Pat wave goodbye in each. The filmmakers never really decided on what they wanted this thing to be about (okay so it is about Wilco, maybe THAT should be enough), then don't have the band talk about random stuff and stick it in. Here are the narrative threads that seem to go nowhere, any of which make a pretty good narrative.
1. Old stuff in America that is disappearing (Pat taking pics around Cains with a Polaroid.) I like this thread because it who doesn't like old stuff that is disappearing in America? I know I do. Great idea, but is only the first one that is giving a few minutes and then never revisited.
2. The death of small towns (John talking about Walmart.) Who doesn't like talking about Walmart? I know I do, it sucks and it sucks the life out of the small towns I have visited. Actually none of the places Wilco even plays in this movie are really small towns. None of the band members even lives in a small town any more.
3. Historic places. Who doesn't love historic places? I know I do. I could have watched an entire concert filmed at Cains, a place I have never been to, but clearly an epicenter of American music. The footage and the feel of the place was great (although the extreme close-ups at the beginning bugged me a bit.) They rushed through each place never giving any of the cities they were in much of their due. Each town is historical and interesting for any number of reasons.
4. How difficult it is being a musican and putting it out every night and the toll it takes on ones body. Of all the narratives that were brought up and dropped, this one was the MOST compelling. The footage of Nels talking about his physical problems and watching Glenn ice down his hands and arms and Jeff being examined (why didn't we get to see the steroid shot?? That would have been great cinema...) were my favorite non-musical parts of the movie. That is not only really interesting as a back story, but something most fans don't think about. They simply think musicians have an easy life and work two hours a day once in awhile. Great stuff, but it was dropped all too quickly.
5. What a brilliant writer and bandleader Jeff is. Who doesn't like hearing that? I knowI do, but once again there was nothing shown about what makes him great and how he writes and what goes into his creative process...zilch.
6. The band members all all talented and unique individuals and make the band what it is. Great. Who doesn't love hearing about the band members?? I know I do. I like all of them. But the sections near the end were gratutious and kind of dumb. How did each member become so wonderful and talented and what brought them to Wilco, which makes Wilco the band it is. All it sounded like was a big circle jerk, no insightinto why these guys are great. If you are fan, like we all are, we know the history of the band members. But to someone watching this who is not aquainted with the band it just sounds stupid. Fortunately John gets the most footage in what was a compelling sequence, although again too short, talking about his musical background. (What were those songs from the 20s and 30s he learned as a kid? I really want to know!!)
7. Fans are important. Who doesn't love seeing the band talk to fans? I know I do, since I love being talked to by the band myself. Those shots are fun and the most compelling footage of this narrative came after the credits with the band's biggest fan of all, Jeff's father, who was funny and engaging.
8. It is a long hard road being in a band and getting gigs and coming up the ladder of success. Who doesn't love hearing about how difficult and long it takes to make it in the music business. I know I do. I talk about this all the time since I have seen bands come and go, some on the verge of making it and just don't make it to the next plateau. What makes Wilco so succussful? This narrative was introduced and dropped. (Incidently it looks like there is a terrific movie about this subject that is just out called Anvil! The Story of Anvil. I can't wait to see this one even though I am not a heavy metal fan. A compelling fllm doesn't even have to be about something you know something about, in fact the joy of seeing a great movie is learning something new about a subject you do now know know anything about, such as an old heavy metal band still trying to make it...)
9.It is possible to pick out a dozen more threads that were not explored. Bands say funny shit in concert, traveling is interesting, boring, tedious, excilerating, stupid (take your pick), it is hard being away from your family as a traveling musician (they miss wives, girlfriends, children, expected children, friends, comforts of home etc.), who are the Total Pros and what is their relationship to the band, why are we showing you soundchecks and not concert footage, how do musicians prepare themselves and practice (OMG the sequence of Glenn practicing, who couldn't watch that all night, I know I could.) Someone else can chime in here if they want before you rip me a new one...
Okay so maybe this is not a flim, maybe this is simply a video. That's fine. I have no problem with that, but as a film, it missed the mark on many occasions and frankly missed some great opportunities to enlighted the rest of the world as to why Wilco is one of the best things on the music scene. The great music movies and you all know what the great ones are (Don't Look Back, the Last Waltz, Stop Making Sense, Spinal Tap, etc.) last because they say something universal and something coherent. Music videos are simply product. This one will please the fans. Personally I am sorry that Live at the Vic never got made. A concert of Wilco in their home town during what was a period of this band when things were just starting to gell Ior actually had gelled) would have been great. (Too bad no one filmed the Otto's shows...) Maybe someday someone will finally edit and mix it and release it. That was a very compelling time for the band and I know I would like to see that. Meanwhile we have a movie of the band in full flower singing and playing their hearts out, with very little understanding of what made this tour important to film.
Sorry to piss people off, but I felt compelled to say these things. Great concert footage, not such a great movie. (and it is Sunday morning so there are lapses in spelling and grammar.)
One last thought before I post this. I Am Trying to Break Your Heart IS a great movie. Long after Ashes is forgotten, we have a movie about Wilco that does tell us why they were and are important and gives a compelling and universal story that anyone can enjoy about a band trying to make good music and be successful. There are parts of that movie that are beautiful, funny, upsetting, triumphant, insightful, artistic, etc. Ashes is nice to look at and sounds great, but is ultimately a bit frustrating and deals with the surface only.
LouieB
Like millions (well maybe thousands) of Wilco fans, I watched the DVD last night. I had seen it at the Music Box a few weeks back so I knew what to expect. I have a few things to say also and the thing about the Tulsa/Nashville thing is something I couldn't know about, but I have some other issues with the movie.
First some of backpedaling before I wade into some shit....I know the band reads stuff here and maybe the film makers do too, I don't know. I am an old fan of Wilco and have talked to all the band members on one occasion or another over the years. They are all massively talented and interesting people. A movie could be made about any one of them and I would buy it or watch it. So just like every other fan here I love seeing and hearing them in the comfort of my livingroom. But if my comments piss some people off, sorry about that.
My issues are not with the band, but with the narrative of the film. I love the concert footage and will watch the movie for that repeatedly in the future, but the flow of the movie (as a film) is so broken up it is very distracting. If all we want (and maybe this is simply a fan movie and nothing else) is to see our favorite band play some songs, this movie fits the bill, but as a movie; well not so much.
Where do I start? Even during the initial viewing at the Music Box, I developed a small internal joke which was "Bye Pat." Seeing snippets of several different shows including some sound checks is really distracting. So we get see Pat wave goodbye in each. The filmmakers never really decided on what they wanted this thing to be about (okay so it is about Wilco, maybe THAT should be enough), then don't have the band talk about random stuff and stick it in. Here are the narrative threads that seem to go nowhere, any of which make a pretty good narrative.
1. Old stuff in America that is disappearing (Pat taking pics around Cains with a Polaroid.) I like this thread because it who doesn't like old stuff that is disappearing in America? I know I do. Great idea, but is only the first one that is giving a few minutes and then never revisited.
2. The death of small towns (John talking about Walmart.) Who doesn't like talking about Walmart? I know I do, it sucks and it sucks the life out of the small towns I have visited. Actually none of the places Wilco even plays in this movie are really small towns. None of the band members even lives in a small town any more.
3. Historic places. Who doesn't love historic places? I know I do. I could have watched an entire concert filmed at Cains, a place I have never been to, but clearly an epicenter of American music. The footage and the feel of the place was great (although the extreme close-ups at the beginning bugged me a bit.) They rushed through each place never giving any of the cities they were in much of their due. Each town is historical and interesting for any number of reasons.
4. How difficult it is being a musican and putting it out every night and the toll it takes on ones body. Of all the narratives that were brought up and dropped, this one was the MOST compelling. The footage of Nels talking about his physical problems and watching Glenn ice down his hands and arms and Jeff being examined (why didn't we get to see the steroid shot?? That would have been great cinema...) were my favorite non-musical parts of the movie. That is not only really interesting as a back story, but something most fans don't think about. They simply think musicians have an easy life and work two hours a day once in awhile. Great stuff, but it was dropped all too quickly.
5. What a brilliant writer and bandleader Jeff is. Who doesn't like hearing that? I knowI do, but once again there was nothing shown about what makes him great and how he writes and what goes into his creative process...zilch.
6. The band members all all talented and unique individuals and make the band what it is. Great. Who doesn't love hearing about the band members?? I know I do. I like all of them. But the sections near the end were gratutious and kind of dumb. How did each member become so wonderful and talented and what brought them to Wilco, which makes Wilco the band it is. All it sounded like was a big circle jerk, no insightinto why these guys are great. If you are fan, like we all are, we know the history of the band members. But to someone watching this who is not aquainted with the band it just sounds stupid. Fortunately John gets the most footage in what was a compelling sequence, although again too short, talking about his musical background. (What were those songs from the 20s and 30s he learned as a kid? I really want to know!!)
7. Fans are important. Who doesn't love seeing the band talk to fans? I know I do, since I love being talked to by the band myself. Those shots are fun and the most compelling footage of this narrative came after the credits with the band's biggest fan of all, Jeff's father, who was funny and engaging.
8. It is a long hard road being in a band and getting gigs and coming up the ladder of success. Who doesn't love hearing about how difficult and long it takes to make it in the music business. I know I do. I talk about this all the time since I have seen bands come and go, some on the verge of making it and just don't make it to the next plateau. What makes Wilco so succussful? This narrative was introduced and dropped. (Incidently it looks like there is a terrific movie about this subject that is just out called Anvil! The Story of Anvil. I can't wait to see this one even though I am not a heavy metal fan. A compelling fllm doesn't even have to be about something you know something about, in fact the joy of seeing a great movie is learning something new about a subject you do now know know anything about, such as an old heavy metal band still trying to make it...)
9.It is possible to pick out a dozen more threads that were not explored. Bands say funny shit in concert, traveling is interesting, boring, tedious, excilerating, stupid (take your pick), it is hard being away from your family as a traveling musician (they miss wives, girlfriends, children, expected children, friends, comforts of home etc.), who are the Total Pros and what is their relationship to the band, why are we showing you soundchecks and not concert footage, how do musicians prepare themselves and practice (OMG the sequence of Glenn practicing, who couldn't watch that all night, I know I could.) Someone else can chime in here if they want before you rip me a new one...
Okay so maybe this is not a flim, maybe this is simply a video. That's fine. I have no problem with that, but as a film, it missed the mark on many occasions and frankly missed some great opportunities to enlighted the rest of the world as to why Wilco is one of the best things on the music scene. The great music movies and you all know what the great ones are (Don't Look Back, the Last Waltz, Stop Making Sense, Spinal Tap, etc.) last because they say something universal and something coherent. Music videos are simply product. This one will please the fans. Personally I am sorry that Live at the Vic never got made. A concert of Wilco in their home town during what was a period of this band when things were just starting to gell Ior actually had gelled) would have been great. (Too bad no one filmed the Otto's shows...) Maybe someday someone will finally edit and mix it and release it. That was a very compelling time for the band and I know I would like to see that. Meanwhile we have a movie of the band in full flower singing and playing their hearts out, with very little understanding of what made this tour important to film.
Sorry to piss people off, but I felt compelled to say these things. Great concert footage, not such a great movie. (and it is Sunday morning so there are lapses in spelling and grammar.)
One last thought before I post this. I Am Trying to Break Your Heart IS a great movie. Long after Ashes is forgotten, we have a movie about Wilco that does tell us why they were and are important and gives a compelling and universal story that anyone can enjoy about a band trying to make good music and be successful. There are parts of that movie that are beautiful, funny, upsetting, triumphant, insightful, artistic, etc. Ashes is nice to look at and sounds great, but is ultimately a bit frustrating and deals with the surface only.
LouieB
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Il n'a pas tort, dans le sens ou Ashes of American Flags n'est pas un film. Il est vrai que l'aspect documentaire reste a la surface des choses, mais ce n'est pas du Michael Moore. Il s'agit juste de mettre d'excellentes prestations dans leur contexte.
Et pour un resident temporaire comme moi, le portrait des villes americaines que l'on trouve en toile de fond est assez ressemblant, je dois dire.
Et pour un resident temporaire comme moi, le portrait des villes americaines que l'on trouve en toile de fond est assez ressemblant, je dois dire.
Yann G.- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 900
Date d'inscription : 09/05/2005
Re: WILCO
En tout cas, la nouvelle pochette confirme la tendance prog du groupe depuis Yankee Hotel Foxtrot. Pink Floyd avait la vache, alors ils ont choisi le chameau.
Alors, certains disent que le chameau forme la lettre "W".
Moi je pense que Jeff Tweedy essaie d'arrêter de fumer.
Alors, certains disent que le chameau forme la lettre "W".
Moi je pense que Jeff Tweedy essaie d'arrêter de fumer.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Je viens de remarquer le chapeau. Cette pochette commence à m'amuser.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Je n'ai toujours pas reçu le Neko Case. Je vais le recommander avec le prochain Wilco.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Hugues a écrit:Je n'ai toujours pas reçu le Neko Case. Je vais le recommander avec le prochain Wilco.
J'attends cela avec impatience , sky blue sky, est un des albums que j'écoute le plus souvent , et depuis pas mal de temps, .... Post d'une extrême indigence.... J'avais juste envie de le dire et comment rivaliser avec une rousse conquérante, haut perchée au regard délicieusement vénimeux. Depuis le temps qu'oncle Hugues multiplie les invitations, je vais m'intéresser à elle, mais comment l'aborder ? (quel album ? Le plus rock ? Avec des guitares, parce que je suis un mec un peu brut de décoffrage et que j'aime la musique rythmée)
Yves Gitton- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 961
Localisation : OISE
Date d'inscription : 02/06/2005
Re: WILCO
Depuis le temps qu'oncle Hugues multiplie les invitations, je vais m'intéresser à elle, mais comment l'aborder ? (quel album ? Le plus rock ? Avec des guitares, parce que je suis un mec un peu brut de décoffrage et que j'aime la musique rythmée)
Le plus rock:
Pour une voix et une vision encore plus hantées:
Comme on peut le constater Neko aime bien se coucher par terre.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Hugues a écrit:Je n'ai toujours pas reçu le Neko Case. Je vais le recommander avec le prochain Wilco.
Le disque de Wilco est en stream sur wilcoworld.net.
Pour l'album de Neko Case, je dois avouer qu'il n'est pas passionnant. J'ai fait l'effort de l'ecouter deux ou trois fois bien, mais ca ne rentre pas dans ma tete, aucune compo ne retient mon attention a part la reprise de Sparks. C'est bien produit, bien joue et bien chante ... mais je ne sais pas, ca ne marche pas trop sur moi, c'est tout. Parfois, faut pas trop chercher ...
Yann G.- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 900
Date d'inscription : 09/05/2005
Re: WILCO
On vient d'apprendre la mort de Jay Bennett
Je lui dois quelques-uns des plus beaux moments pop-musicaux qu'il m'ait été donné d'écouter, puisqu'il est responsable des arrangements de synthés et claviers de Summerteeth, un des plus beaux albums de tous les temps.
Il avait écrit et composé notamment "My Darling" (chanté par Jeff Tweedy):
Comme on peut le lire sur le lien ci-dessus, Jay Bennett avait appelé son propre studio d'enregistrement Pieholden Suites, d'après la chanson de Summerteeth qui illustre parfaitement ses talents d'arrangeur. Il se trouve que c'est aussi ma chanson préférée de Wilco. En la réécoutant, il me serait difficile de changer d'avis: c'est un chef d'oeuvre.
Je lui dois quelques-uns des plus beaux moments pop-musicaux qu'il m'ait été donné d'écouter, puisqu'il est responsable des arrangements de synthés et claviers de Summerteeth, un des plus beaux albums de tous les temps.
Il avait écrit et composé notamment "My Darling" (chanté par Jeff Tweedy):
Comme on peut le lire sur le lien ci-dessus, Jay Bennett avait appelé son propre studio d'enregistrement Pieholden Suites, d'après la chanson de Summerteeth qui illustre parfaitement ses talents d'arrangeur. Il se trouve que c'est aussi ma chanson préférée de Wilco. En la réécoutant, il me serait difficile de changer d'avis: c'est un chef d'oeuvre.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Assez peu d'info sur ce deces d'ailleurs qui intervient au moment ou Bennett avait decide de poursuivre Tweedy pour des royalties qu'il n'aurait pas touche pour le DVD I Am Trying To Break Your Heart ou il n'apparaissait pas sous son meilleur jour, il faut dire ...
Yann G.- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 900
Date d'inscription : 09/05/2005
Re: WILCO
J'ai adoré Sky Blue Sky, après une écoute Wilco The Album m'a fortement ennuyé n'en déplaise au grand timonier. Mais je ne m'avoue pas vaincu facilement et pour ce prix là j'y retourne pour voir si quelque chose grandi en moi, comme disait Brigitte Lahaie dans les cabines d'essayage de la Samaritaine.
basil- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 1032
Localisation : torquay
Date d'inscription : 02/05/2005
Re: WILCO
Hélas, je suis aussi de ceux que (the album) ennuie. C'est leur moins bon depuis A.M..
Je donnerais un 2 sur 5, comme note. Je ne verrais pas l'intérêt d'un 3. Si vous voulez découvrir Wilco, commencez ailleurs. Si vous les connaissez déjà et n'aimez pas particulièrement, laissez tomber. Si vous êtes fan, vous l'avez déjà de toute façon.
Je donnerais un 2 sur 5, comme note. Je ne verrais pas l'intérêt d'un 3. Si vous voulez découvrir Wilco, commencez ailleurs. Si vous les connaissez déjà et n'aimez pas particulièrement, laissez tomber. Si vous êtes fan, vous l'avez déjà de toute façon.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
je ne sais pas ce que Hugues en pensera (grand spécialiste de Wilco) mais "You never know" ça me fait penser à du Tom Petty reprenant du George Harrison.
walpurgis- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 608
Date d'inscription : 08/04/2005
Re: WILCO
walpurgis a écrit:je ne sais pas ce que Hugues en pensera (grand spécialiste de Wilco) mais "You never know" ça me fait penser à du Tom Petty reprenant du George Harrison.
Donc du Traveling Wilburys? Non, pas possible, ça se saurait...
Quiet Man- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 1297
Localisation : Plateau de Millevaches
Date d'inscription : 19/03/2007
Re: WILCO
écoutez le solo : on dirait un peu celui de my sweet lord
walpurgis- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 608
Date d'inscription : 08/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Je vais réécouter ce morceau dès que je suis chez moi pour te dire ce que j'en pense (ça tombe bien, j'ai réécouté "My Sweet Lord" récemment - j'ai fait une compile de l'année 70 pour un collègue dont c'est l'année de naissance).
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Alors oui, le refrain "I don't caaaaare anymore" est plaqué sur les mêmes accords que la légendaire intro de "My Sweet Lord", et on y trouve même un petit glissando de guitare qui a presque l'air d'un clin d'oeil à celui du Doux Seigneur, mais j'ignore si ce fut délibéré. Il faut savoir que Wilco est un réservoir d'influences de pop classique - au point que certains les considèrent comme un groupe de plagiaires sans grand intérêt (Yann va s'offusquer et traîter ces "certains" de crétins, mais non, ça peut se comprendre, même si c'est assurément une critique relativement impertinente).
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Re: WILCO
en tout cas, j'aime vraiment beaucoup ce morceau sous influence, mais je ne pense pas que ce soient des plagiaires.
Ici, c'est plutôt un clin d'oeil, un hommage.
Ici, c'est plutôt un clin d'oeil, un hommage.
walpurgis- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 608
Date d'inscription : 08/04/2005
Re: WILCO
Hugues a écrit:certains les considèrent comme un groupe de plagiaires sans grand intérêt (Yann va s'offusquer et traîter ces "certains" de crétins, mais non, ça peut se comprendre, même si c'est assurément une critique relativement impertinente).
Je confirme. Qui que soient ces crétins, ils ont une bien piètre idée de ce qu'est la pop music. La pop music est par définition une musique de plagiaire qui agit comme une éponge et se nourrit de l'imaginaire collectif. Enfin, on a le droit de penser ce qu'on veut mais après, faut pas de plaindre si on se fait ratatiner en retour ...
Yann G.- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 900
Date d'inscription : 09/05/2005
Re: WILCO
Bien vu les gars, ce titre est un mix entre jammin' me de Petty avec le solo de my sweet lord, mais c'est tellement gros que ça ne peut qu'être un hommage, en tout cas c'est bien agréable.
johnny99- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 2158
Date d'inscription : 25/05/2005
Re: WILCO
Yann G. a écrit:
Je confirme. Qui que soient ces crétins, ils ont une bien piètre idée de ce qu'est la pop music. La pop music est par définition une musique de plagiaire qui agit comme une éponge et se nourrit de l'imaginaire collectif. Enfin, on a le droit de penser ce qu'on veut mais après, faut pas de plaindre si on se fait ratatiner en retour ...
L'un de ces crétins est Thom Jurek (que j'admire). Et effectivement, la pop il s'en fout, il en est resté aux Beatles. Il est plus intéressé par la fusion des genres, jazz et groove notamment, si possible à caractère social, et il cultive aussi les singer songwriters. Il porte aux nues Bruce Springsteen (bien qu'il ait détesté le dernier disque) et les Go-Betweens, entre autres (beaucoup, beaucoup d'autres). Il met aussi Lennon au même rang que Dylan et Van Morrison - et ça, c'est classe.
Bon, je dis tout ça après avoir lu ses chroniques (il en écrit dix par jour), mais lui, ne revendique rien.
Hugues- Langue pendue
- Nombre de messages : 10809
Age : 55
Localisation : Manosque
Date d'inscription : 05/04/2005
Page 2 sur 2 • 1, 2
Page 2 sur 2
Permission de ce forum:
Vous ne pouvez pas répondre aux sujets dans ce forum
|
|